5 Best Hole-in-the-Wall Restaurants in Bloomington, Indiana

Bloomington, Indiana, is more than just a college town—it’s a city with a diverse and vibrant food scene.

Here are five hole-in-the-wall restaurants in Bloomington that offer unique and unforgettable dining experiences.

Mother Bear’s Pizza

Mother Bear’s Pizza is a beloved local spot known for its fantastic pizza and cozy, inviting atmosphere.

Start with their Divine Swine Pizza, loaded with pepperoni, sausage, ham, and bacon.

Try their Cheese Sticks, which are served with a side of their rich, house-made marinara sauce.

For a twist, order the Spinach Artichoke Dip, a creamy and flavorful appetizer that’s perfect for sharing.

The warm ambiance and delicious menu make Mother Bear’s Pizza a must-visit for pizza lovers.

The Owlery

The Owlery offers scrumptious vegetarian and vegan cuisine that even meat lovers will enjoy.

Order the Buffalo Tempeh, spicy and tangy, served with a side of vegan ranch.

The Vegan Poutine, featuring crispy fries topped with vegan cheese curds and gravy, is a standout.

Don’t miss their Sweet Potato Tacos, packed with flavor and topped with cilantro-lime slaw.

With its laid-back vibe and creative menu, The Owlery is a hidden gem for plant-based dining.

Nick’s English Hut

Nick’s English Hut is a time-honored establishment known for its hearty American fare and historic charm.

Start with the Nick’s Famous Stromboli, filled with layers of cheese, salami, ham, and pepperoni.

The Cheddar Burger, juicy and topped with melted cheddar, lettuce, and tomato, is a local favorite.

For something a bit lighter, try the Grilled Chicken Salad, featuring fresh greens and a tangy house dressing.

With its rich history and inviting atmosphere, Nick’s English Hut is a staple in the Bloomington dining scene.

Dats

Dats brings the flavors of New Orleans to Bloomington with its authentic and bold Creole and Cajun dishes.

Try the Jambalaya, a hearty dish loaded with sausage, chicken, shrimp, and spices.

The Crawfish Etouffee, rich and flavorful, is served over a bed of fluffy rice.

For a quick snack, the Beignets, light and airy with a dusting of powdered sugar, are perfect.

The vibrant atmosphere and mouthwatering dishes make Dats a must-visit for anyone craving Cajun cuisine.

Samira

Samira offers delicious Afghan cuisine in a cozy and welcoming setting.

Start with the Aushak, pasta filled with leeks and topped with a savory meat sauce and yogurt.

The Kebabs, tender and flavorful, are served with perfectly seasoned rice and fresh bread.

Don’t miss the Baklava, a sweet and nutty dessert that pairs perfectly with a cup of Afghan tea.

With its authentic flavors and warm hospitality, Samira is a hidden gem for those seeking Afghan cuisine.