Columbus, Ohio, is a city bursting with incredible food experiences, many of which are found in its unassuming, hole-in-the-wall restaurants.
Here are five hidden gems that you absolutely must try for a truly unique culinary adventure.
Johnnie’s Tavern
Johnnie’s Tavern is a NorthWest Columbus favorite, known for its incredible burgers and fries.
Start with their legendary Jumbo Cheeseburger, which many claim to be the best in Columbus.
Pair your burger with their perfectly crispy French Fries, seasoned just right for an ideal side.
The black leather bar seats and checkered tablecloths add a nostalgic charm that makes you feel right at home.
With its cozy, laid-back vibe, Johnnie’s Tavern is the perfect spot for comfort food done right.
Fat Baxter’s
Fat Baxter’s in Hilltop is a must-visit for those who crave excellent tavern fare.
Their Buffalo Wings, known for their outstanding flavor and perfect level of crispiness, are a local favorite.
Don’t miss out on the Chili Cheese Coneys, which are hearty and packed with robust flavors.
They also serve an excellent brunch with dishes like Corned Beef Hash and Eggs Keep that keep patrons coming back.
The friendly atmosphere and fantastic food make Fat Baxter’s a standout spot in Columbus.
The Walrus
The Walrus downtown offers a truly unique bar and dining experience.
Their Maple Burger, featuring a juicy patty topped with sweet maple onions and sharp cheddar, is a must-try.
Pair your burger with their Signature Fries, which are served with a house-made dipping sauce that elevates the whole meal.
The unassuming storefront, complete with a glass garage door, adds to the quirky charm of this hidden gem.
With a lively atmosphere and a menu full of surprises, The Walrus is a beloved downtown destination.
The Old Mohawk
The Old Mohawk in German Village is a historical landmark that serves up delicious, comforting fare.
Their Turtle Soup, a unique and traditional dish, is a rare and delightful find in Columbus.
Try the Mohawk Burger, stacked high with toppings and cooked to perfection.
The rich history and classic decor create a nostalgic setting that enhances the dining experience.
With friendly service and a welcoming vibe, The Old Mohawk is a cherished staple in German Village.
Over the Counter
Over the Counter in Worthington offers a delightful retro dining experience with its diner-style menu.
Start with their Patty Melt, which features a juicy burger and melted cheese on perfectly grilled rye bread.
Their Weekend Brunch is also popular, offering dishes like Eggs Benedict and fluffy pancakes that attract a crowd.
Vegetarians will appreciate the many options tailored to their tastes, ensuring everyone can enjoy a meal here.
With its nostalgic 50’s charm and welcoming service, Over the Counter is a delightful place to dine.
Get the All-American Travel Secrets!
Don't miss out on America's hidden gems!
