5 Best Columbus Italian Restaurants in Ohio

Columbus, Ohio, known for its vibrant arts scene, diverse culture, and welcoming community, is also home to an impressive culinary landscape.

Among the many dining options available, Italian cuisine holds a special place for its rich flavors, comforting dishes, and convivial atmosphere.

Whether you’re craving classic pasta dishes, wood-fired pizzas, or innovative takes on traditional recipes, Columbus offers a range of Italian restaurants that provide a delightful dining experience.

Here’s an in-depth look at the five best Italian restaurants in Columbus, each known for their exceptional food, unique ambiance, and commitment to quality.

1. Marcella’s Ristorante, Pizzeria & Wine Bar

Overview

Located at 615 N High Street in the bustling Short North Arts District, Marcella’s Ristorante, Pizzeria & Wine Bar offers a lively and inviting atmosphere with a menu that celebrates traditional Italian cuisine.

Part of the Cameron Mitchell Restaurants group, Marcella’s is known for its authentic flavors, extensive wine list, and vibrant setting.

What to Try

• Spaghetti Carbonara: Classic pasta dish made with pancetta, egg, Pecorino Romano, and black pepper, creating a rich and creamy sauce.
• Margherita Pizza: Wood-fired pizza topped with fresh tomatoes, mozzarella, and basil, offering a simple yet delicious flavor profile.
• Tiramisu: Marcella’s tiramisu is a must-try, featuring layers of espresso-soaked ladyfingers and mascarpone cream, topped with cocoa powder.

Ambiance

Marcella’s exudes a warm and lively atmosphere with its open kitchen, rustic decor, and bustling bar area.

The vibrant setting and friendly service make it a perfect spot for both casual dinners and special occasions.

2. Basi Italia

Overview

Situated at 811 Highland Street in the historic Victorian Village, Basi Italia is a charming and intimate restaurant that offers a creative take on Italian cuisine.

Chef and owner John Dornback focuses on seasonal ingredients and innovative recipes, creating dishes that are both unique and flavorful.

What to Try

• Zucchini Pronto: A signature appetizer featuring thinly sliced zucchini rolled with goat cheese and drizzled with balsamic reduction.
• Tagliatelle Bolognese: Handcrafted tagliatelle pasta served with a rich and hearty Bolognese sauce, topped with freshly grated Parmesan cheese.
• Bread Pudding: For dessert, the bread pudding at Basi Italia is a standout, featuring a moist and flavorful pudding served with a bourbon caramel sauce.

Ambiance

Basi Italia offers a cozy and intimate setting with its quaint decor, soft lighting, and outdoor patio.

The charming atmosphere and attentive service make it ideal for romantic dinners and special gatherings.

3. Due Amici

Overview

Located at 67 E Gay Street in downtown Columbus, Due Amici offers a modern and stylish dining experience with a menu that blends traditional Italian flavors with contemporary flair.

Executive Chef Matt Clemence emphasizes fresh, high-quality ingredients and creative presentations, making Due Amici a standout in the city’s dining scene.

What to Try

• Pappardelle alla Bolognese: Wide ribbon pasta served with a savory Bolognese sauce made from beef, pork, and veal, topped with Parmesan cheese.
• Veal Marsala: Tender veal cutlets cooked with mushrooms and Marsala wine, served with a side of pasta or vegetables.
• Cannoli: For dessert, the cannoli at Due Amici are a must-try, featuring crispy shells filled with sweet ricotta and chocolate chips.

Ambiance

Due Amici features a contemporary and elegant ambiance with its modern decor, open kitchen, and spacious dining area.

The sophisticated setting and innovative dishes make it perfect for both casual outings and upscale dining experiences.

4. G. Michael’s Bistro & Bar

Overview

Situated at 595 S 3rd Street in the historic German Village, G. Michael’s Bistro & Bar offers a refined dining experience with a menu that highlights Southern-inspired Italian cuisine.

Chef David Tetzloff combines his Southern roots with Italian culinary traditions, creating dishes that are both comforting and elegant.

What to Try

• Shrimp and Grits: A Southern classic with an Italian twist, featuring sautéed shrimp served over creamy Parmesan grits with a rich tomato-basil sauce.
• Osso Buco: Braised veal shank served with a flavorful sauce, accompanied by a creamy risotto, offering a hearty and satisfying dish.
• Panna Cotta: For dessert, the panna cotta at G. Michael’s is silky and smooth, served with a berry compote.

Ambiance

G. Michael’s offers a warm and inviting atmosphere with its historic charm, cozy decor, and attentive service.

The elegant setting and unique menu make it an excellent choice for special occasions and romantic dinners.

5. Lola & Giuseppe’s Trattoria

Overview

Located at 100 Granville Street in Gahanna, just outside Columbus, Lola & Giuseppe’s Trattoria is a family-owned restaurant that brings the essence of Italy to the local community.

Known for its homely atmosphere and authentic recipes, Lola & Giuseppe’s has become a beloved spot for both locals and visitors.

What to Try

• Lasagna Bolognese: Layers of pasta, rich meat sauce, creamy ricotta, and melted mozzarella, baked to perfection and served with a side of garlic bread.
• Chicken Piccata: Tender chicken breasts cooked with capers, lemon, and white wine, served with a side of pasta or vegetables.
• Sfogliatella: For dessert, the sfogliatella is a must-try, featuring a crispy pastry shell filled with sweet ricotta and citrus zest.

Ambiance

Lola & Giuseppe’s Trattoria exudes a cozy and welcoming atmosphere with its rustic decor, warm lighting, and family-friendly vibe.

The inviting setting and delicious food make it perfect for family meals and casual dining.

Conclusion

Columbus, Ohio, boasts a diverse and vibrant Italian dining scene that caters to all tastes and preferences.

From the lively and inviting atmosphere of Marcella’s Ristorante, Pizzeria & Wine Bar to the charming and intimate setting of Basi Italia, each of these top five Italian restaurants offers a unique and memorable dining experience.

Whether you’re a local resident or a visitor, these restaurants are sure to satisfy your cravings and provide a true taste of Italy in the heart of Ohio.